失控

Clarifying user request

The user wrote a Chinese sentence about discussing Chinese football youth training. It seems they may want to chat about this with a former CSL star. I need to clarify what the user specifically wants: Are they looking for an interview outline, talking points, or an analysis of the youth training system? Possible topics include problems, data, comparisons with other countries, and suggested solutions. I should respond in Chinese and be concise while offering a structured approach.Proposing interview deliverables

I'm thinking about what deliverables to propose. Perhaps I could suggest a 60-90 minute interview outline, a list of relevant topics and controversial angles, and data points up to my knowledge cutoff in October 2024. Comparing Chinese youth training policies with those from Japan, South Korea, Germany, and Spain could be valuable too. I might include a timeline of policies, pitfalls to avoid, and ideas for follow-up content. Keeping it straightforward, I can use simple bullet points without heavy formatting.Identifying key talking points

I’m considering key talking points for the discussion. Important topics might include funding transparency, the disconnect between schools and clubs, and the focus on tournaments versus training. Issues like the lack of qualified coaches, pay-to-play models, and biases in player selection could be critical. It’s also essential to mention the effects of biological age, late development, and the shortcomings of the scouting system. We should touch on regional FA differences, league instability, and match exposure for the U17-U23 age groups, ensuring accuracy throughout.Proposing interview questions and topics

![ys](/assets/images/A9301B92.jpg)

I’m thinking about the interview with an ex-CSL star and what sample questions to propose. I could ask about his youth experiences, opinions on training content, and skill fundamentals. Some interesting angles might include decision-making, cognitive training, small-sided games, and coaching licenses. It might also be worth discussing academy budgets, return on investment, and how U23 policies have created unintended consequences, like inflated salaries for unprepared players. I want to ensure the questions cover critical aspects effectively.Crafting the interview structure

I’m considering how to incorporate data from Asian peers like Japan’s JFA and Korea’s KFA, which have effective training structures. I want to prepare a conversational flow that includes an opening, personal narrative, diagnosing issues, money flows, and competition ecosystems. Additionally, I’ll include actionable proposals for reform like upgrading coach status and rebuilding the competition pyramid.

It’s essential to create a clear outline with bullet points, while being mindful of sensitivity when crafting questions for the former player. I need to clarify what format the user is planning—podcast, article, or video—and the length, as that will guide my approach.

你是要做一次对谈/采访吗?我先给你一套可直接落地的采访大纲、关键事实与“坑点”提醒,够你和任意一位前中超名将把中国青训这本“乱账”聊透;如果你告诉我节目的时长(比如30/60/90分钟)和嘉宾姓名/位置,我再按风格细化到逐问逐答稿。

— 核心结构(建议60–90分钟)

— 重点话题与可追问点

  1. 现状“乱账”三要素
  1. 资金与激励
  1. 教练与训练方法
  1. 竞赛与上升通道
  1. 选材、公平与家长角色
  1. 国外可借鉴但需本土化的做法

— 可直接用的问题清单(含追问)

  1. 你小时候一周训练/比赛各多少?和你现在看到的U13–U15相比,差别最大是什么?
  2. 如果用三句话定义“青训乱账”,你会说哪三条?
  3. 一支中超俱乐部一年愿意在U梯队花多少钱才算“真的想培养”?钱主要花在什么上最有效?
  4. 你心目中最好的U12–U14训练课,前15分钟在练什么?最后15分钟在练什么?
  5. 我们在选材时是不是太看重“身体条件”?你见过的“晚熟逆袭”案例能具体讲讲吗?
  6. 家长付费、进一线队机会、上学出路,这三个目标如何平衡?你建议家长在U12、U15、U17各做什么选择?
  7. U23政策带来了哪些积极和副作用?如果你是总监,下一版政策怎么改才能让教练“愿意也敢用新人”?
  8. 你最佩服的本土青训教练是谁?他/她的训练细节有哪两点值得全国推广?
  9. 青少年比赛应该打多少场才够?现在的联赛/杯赛在节奏与质量上最大痛点是什么?
  10. 你如何看“年龄作假”?如果只给你一个工具防治,你会选什么(骨龄、长期档案、跨省联动数据等)?
  11. 我们为什么难以产出顶级中场/前腰?在U10–U14阶段最应该怎么练“决策与视野”?
  12. 伤病与负荷:你青年时期最常见的伤是什么?今天的小球员伤更重还是更轻?为什么?
  13. 教练的职业吸引力:怎样的薪级、晋升与继续教育能留住好教练?
  14. 如果给你3年预算,建立一个地区试点,你的KPI只留三个,你选什么?
  15. 给现在在梯队的孩子一句话建议,给家长一句话建议,给管理者一句话建议

— 数据与事实卡(对外表述建议保留区间,避免绝对值)

— 典型“坑点”提醒(避免对谈失控或空转)

— 可落地的改进清单(引导嘉宾“给方案”)

  1. 教练优先:将青训教练纳入长期合同与继续教育基金;区分级别设工资与晋升通道
  2. 比赛密度表:为U10–U19设“年度有效比赛场次/周训练时长”红线,联赛与杯赛围绕红线设计
  3. 激励改造:以“自愿但强激励”的方式奖励本土U21上场分钟与输送转会,替代一刀切强制
  4. 选材与档案:建立跨地区统一球员ID与成长档案;严管年龄校验,配合长期追踪而非一次性检测
  5. 试点思路:挑3–5个地市做全链条试点(校园联赛+俱乐部合作+医训康复+家长教育),一年复盘、三年扩散
  6. 降低家长成本:以公共场地、地区基金与校社共建的方式,降低“付费门槛”,扩大基数

— 节目呈现“爆点”与金句角度

需要我:

  1. 按你锁定的嘉宾(位置:后卫/中场/前锋;是否退役)改写为个性化提纲?
  2. 准备主持人开场白和结语(1–2分钟成稿),以及中场过渡语?
  3. 补一页“地区试点方案”或“U12–U15训练周计划”作为节目彩蛋下载?

告诉我你的节目时长、渠道(播客/视频/长文)和嘉宾信息,我马上细化到逐问逐答与控时。